ER documentary tells some truths about war

David Steinbruner, the author of the piece I just posted here, is one of the emergency physicians featured in the new documentary ‘Baghdad ER’ that HBO will be screening this coming weekend.
CNN had this pre-release description of the movie on their website last week. (Also here.) Read the description there. It makes me definitely want to see the movie, though we don’t have HBO.
The WaPo’s Paul Farhi had a short report in today’s paper about a special screening of the movie that was held Monday night at the National Museum of American History. The main thrust of Farhi’s piece was to note that the support the Pentagon once had for the movie project has waned drastically in recent weeks.
He writes:

    HBO executives say that top Army officials expressed enthusiasm for the documentary in March, but that the Pentagon’s support has waned. They believe the military is troubled by the film’s unflinching look at the consequences of the war on American soldiers, and that it might diminish public support.
    The documentary, shot over 2 1/2 months in mid-2005, contains graphic and disturbing footage of soldiers reeling from their wounds — in some cases, dying of them — as Army medical personnel try to save them. The film illustrates the compassion and dedication of the staff of the 86th Combat Support Hospital in Baghdad. But it also has many gruesome images, such as shots of soldiers’ amputated limbs being dumped into trash bags, and pools of blood and viscera being mopped from a busy operating room floor. At one point, an Army chaplain, reciting last rites for a soldier, calls all the violence “senseless.”
    … The network screened the film in mid-March for senior Army officials, including Secretary of the Army Francis J. Harvey, and received an enthusiastic response, said Richard Plepler, HBO’s executive vice president.
    … Thereafter, Plepler said, the Army’s support began to evaporate. The network’s offer to co-sponsor a screening of the film this week at Fort Campbell, Ky., the home of the 86th, was turned down by the Pentagon without explanation. The Army wasn’t an official sponsor of Monday’s screening, and none of the service’s highest-ranking officers or senior medical personnel attended, despite HBO’s invitation.

Farhi also wrote this:

    Among the guests in attendance was Paula Zwillinger, whose son, Marine Lance Cpl. Robert Mininger, 21, died in Iraq from injuries from a roadside bomb. Zwillinger said in an interview that she didn’t know exactly how her son died until the film’s producers — Joseph Feury, Jon Alpert and Matthew O’Neill — contacted her as they were editing the film. Mininger’s death is chronicled in a prolonged sequence at the end of “Baghdad ER.”
    She called the film a gift. “It gave me peace. At least I know he was with someone, and didn’t die alone,” she said.
    Despite the grim subject matter, Zwillinger said: “I am positive about this film. It needs to be shown. I want the world to know this is reality. War is graphic, war is raw, war hurts. And we need more support for our troops, no matter what we think of the war.”

One thought on “ER documentary tells some truths about war”

  1. I want the world to know this is reality. War is graphic, war is raw, and war hurts. And we need more support for our troops, no matter what we think of the war.”
    Whose the world you asking to see this film? You put yourself in this war, you went to a country living in a peace people loves their land, you looted, destroyed their country their homes their life’s, their daily services and needs and you like the world to see you “hurts”.
    Is not ironic that some one hurts himself and asked others to see how much he suffer how ironic things here.
    It’s better to take your film and show it to those who lead you who are in command of you to those who recruited you, to those who lied to you.
    Your troops killing innocent Iraqis for no reasons just because you call them “Terrorists” or “Insurgences” as they fights for their living and their life, your killing of Iraqis is to feed your hunger for killing and blood, its past the reality its become a crazy job for your troops using those mercenaries, gangs, spices all sort of intelligences working madly to kill to loot to distract a country because of you and your administration whom you elected to leads you to this disastrous case.
    Did you think for moment what happened to Iraqis, in Abu Grab Prisoners, in Boka Prisons?
    Did you film Al Faluja killing?
    Did you film your troops what they did in Tel-A’afer?
    Did you film your tropes when they destroyed the water Treatments Plants and supplies in Haditha, Anna, Al-Baghdadi, Tel A’afer and other places your troops went to targeted the insurgencies?
    Why Water Treatments Plants?
    Are those insurgences hid under the water in those Storage Tanks?
    Did you film your Group of Engineers who destroyed the Water Dame?
    Did you film the four came from US full of mouse you will find it their in the ships they landed in Basra?
    Did you film and talked to Iraqi Trucks Drivers those they carry that flour with heaps of mouse jumping and playing? Or that came from Australia full of pieces of irons?
    Did you heared this “ Basra carnage escalates as one person killed every hour
    What we can say just let the Iraqis alone leave their country save your lives and the lives of Iraqis they will call you as friends to help them when they need to believe me. They not hate you…

Comments are closed.