Condolences to friends in China, Myanmar/Burma

I know I’m late saying this, but I want to send heartfelt condolences to everyone in China and Myanmar/Burma whose universe has been shattered by the loss of loved ones, homes, or livelihoods due to Cyclone Nargis and China’s earthquake. The pictures, whenever I see them, are all searing, and I wish comfort and strength to all the traumatized surviving people of the two devastated areas.
I continue to be extremely concerned about the endlessly mean-spirited, politicized, and accusatory way in which most of the western MSM has covered the Myanmar losses. Today, even the WaPo’s usually wise Al Kamen got into the act, writing, “Human rights advocates were wincing at a photo on the wires of Agency for International Development chief Henrietta Fore shaking hands and beaming with a Burmese military thug at the Rangoon airport a few days ago.” Come on! Fore was delivering aid, and the Burmese officer was receiving it. In the circumstances, it was quite appropriate that both were smiling. Why refer to him in this context as “a Burmese military thug”?
I think that one thing that most western human rights activists and their many friends in the MSM, like Al Kamen, fail to understand is that humanitarian action– action that is designed purely at reducing the immediate suffering of our fellow-humans– should have its own space, quite insulated from the concerns of politicians and of the west’s self-styled (and often quite heavily politicized) “human rights advocates.”
Would Kamen and his “human rights advocate” friends have preferred that Fore had not delivered the aid? Or that she had delivered it while wagging a harsh accusatory finger at the general (thereby most likely dooming her ability to ever deliver any more aid?)
All quite bizarre: childishly accusatory and revealing these people’s deep ignorance of the meaning of humanitarian solidarity.
The western MSM’s coverage of China has generally been a lot better. But even there, I have seen unsubstantiated and quite inappropriate accusations of governmental ineptitude. On ABC News last night, a correspondent in one of the horrendously affected cities urgently told the camera something like, “Here, too, there has been a large degree of chaos. People have even had to stand in line for drinking water!”
Now the second of those statements quite obviously negates the first. When people stand in line for a scarce and desperately needed commodity, that denotes not “chaos”, but its opposite. And indeed, in the frame behind him we saw people standing in an orderly line awaiting their bottled water handouts.
Has that reporter ever seen “chaos”, I wonder?
Anyway, my media criticism is for now quite secondary to my desire to express my human solidarity with all those affected and with all those in those two countries who working so hard to help them.
For anyone seeking a range of (generally) non-politicized reports of the aid efforts that Burmese and non-Burmese bodies are undertaking inside the country, Reliefweb can give you lots of solid, up-to-date news. For example, this from Malteser International about the work of some of the 200 staff members they now have working in the country.
The report states: “As Malteser International has been able to start the relief activities in the disaster area right after the Cyclone, they are now also bundling the assistance of other organisations and partners and implementing it.”
They’re appealing urgently for funds and provide details of a bank account based in Koln, Germany, to donate to:

    Donation Account 120 120 120
    Bank für Sozialwirtschaft, Wörthstr. 15 – 17, D-50668 Köln
    Sort Code : 370 205 00
    IBAN : DE49 3702 0500 0001 0258 01
    BIC: BFSWDE33XXX
    Reference : “Cyclone Nargis”

3 thoughts on “Condolences to friends in China, Myanmar/Burma”

  1. Although your work is honored in this case Helena, US senators approved billions of dollars for the distraction of Iraqi nation, it’s better of asking your administration to have some humanity to use some billions of distraction money to rescue those caught by God disaster not man made one who are urgent need for every cent to be helped and rescued isn’t Helena?

  2. I would think there is an obvious question for the American MSM once it decided to focus on denouncing such an obvious target as the Myanmar government.
    Why not enforce democracy for Myanmar through immediate occupation? Isn’t it far more brutally oppressed right now than even the US MSM ever pretended Iraq was? And American soliders really might be greeted as liberators there by many right now. With barriers to aid removed by force you actually could even at this late stage save many many thousands of lives, even though undoubtedly at the tragic cost of a much small number.
    But then we all know no nation ever starts a war and then occupies a remote country to improve the lives of foreign citizens. So in reality all you can really do is put a dollar or two in the charity pot, and work out how far more will be “democraticly” taken from your taxes (and your childrens for many years to come)to fund harm and oppresion in Iraq.

Comments are closed.